Players verus the GM (Part 2)

The post breaking down the various Players versus the GM responses was getting a bit long and unwieldy, so here's the second part of it.

Totally agreed. 

Yeah, this is how I run my games, but I know that a lot of GMs don't run their games like this. I've sat with GMs who've done antagonism well, and others who have done it very poorly, including games I've just flat-out walked away from.

Once again we're looking at the split between diegetic and non-diegetic in the session. However, in many of the more memorable sessions I've been a part of, players have been playing with the GM, while their characters have been fighting against a combination of adversities created by the GM, by each other, and by the reactions in the world that are showing them accountability for their own actions. When the session starts, characters with true agency won't know where they're gong to end up, they just know that it's going to be an interesting and meandering path that will get them to a resolution of some kind. On a more railroady game, I can see that the players and characters are pulling toward the satisfying conclusion, while the GM is pulling the other way to prevent the characters from getting to a satisfying conclusion. However this doesn't allow agency from the characters... it's very pass/fail, momentum/no-momentum... very "play the scenario by the book" D&D.

 

Common, yes. Inevitable, no. I've already pointed out the "Gygax/Arneson" divide in the earliest days when the groundwork for Chainmail/proto-D&D was developed in the Braunstein days. Again, this comes down to the range of choices given to the characters, and how well the system facilitates those choices or translates them into the diegetic narrative. No set of rules will perfectly emulate every set of choices, or every set of outcomes. When it comes to "clear and strict" rules that need to be adhered to in order to get the designers intended experience, look no further than PbtA games. In these, players literally can't do anything beyond their moves, and they have to narratively shift the fiction until one of their moves becomes relevant. In such a case, the game is less about players versus the adversity established by the GM, and more about the drama as different players work to shift the narrative toward their own agendas (which may inadvertently shift the narrative away from the agendas of the other players and their characters). The GM is either pulling with the rules, or working with the players to pull against them.

 

100%. Different groups will enjoy different styles of game. No one game is a perfect fit for every table, and claiming that there is only one right way to participate in TTRPGs is driving many folks away from the hobby rather than opening up a diversity of experiences to grow it.

Naturally, I'm agreeing with this one. The last point here gets so close to what I've been describing in the 3-way tension. At different times, different factors are influencing and pulling on the narrative and the characters choices within that narrative. A player holistically considering the impact of their choices with regard to the session may factor in the impact this will have on the environment presented by the GM, the infuence this will have on the choices available to the other characters, or the way the game systems will interact with those choices and filter their results back into the diegetic environment of the setting. Even the simplest of games and simplest of sessions will often allow for this complexity, and for me that's all a part of a richness of the hobby. 

Session zero sometimes happens informally. I prefer it when a GM tells me how their going to run a game, and whether they're going to be presenting in "harcore mode", but a lot of GMs just develop a reputation and will xdraw certain types of players to their games because that's what those players expect. The "session zero" consists of word-of-mouth before the players sit down at the table and start their diegetic experience. If I was told that we were expecting an existential character study, only to be confronted with murder-hoboes, that's when I wouldn't be happy.

What's wrong with group therapy? TTRPGs are gaining massive popularity as a therapy tool because they provide a safe liminal space for the exploration of ideas and choices. This is a really narrow take that certainly verges on the idea of "No, you're playing it wrong!!" nonsense.

 

There it is... an alternate description of the tension that drives what I've been talking about all these years. The push and pull is the essence of it. A bit of resistance shows that the effort is required, otherwise there would be no need for heroes, and no meaningful decisions in the world. Too much resistance and both the players and their characters are demoralised by the futility of their actions in the face of it all. This is a really interesting dial that can dramatically alter the flavour and mood of a game (among others).

This aligns with what I said in the previous post about the convention team "Demolition". I wonder if this guy is a Sydney local, or if the idea of a team like this is a common worldwide phenomenon. I've often found that it's only possible for players like this to break things if they derail a game that is on a fixed railroad path, or if they are presented with obstacles that don't make diegetic sense. 

 

Not always... as indicated previously, sometimes the players set up the conflicts. They might work against one another, or the might create situations where the ramifications of their actions come back to haunt them. The GM helps to facilitate the experience, helps them negotiate the rules and helps to set up an environment in which the choices of the characters have meaning and consequence. Otherwise, generally I agree here, it's a collective experience and everyone should be getting more positives from the session than negative, otherwise the hobby feels like wasted time.

 

That's about as far as I got with the cutting and pasting of comments, but in the days since I first posted these, I've seen a few similar types of posts in a certain Facebook group, all coming from the same person. Some of the questions feel like engagement bait (which basically worked as a prompt for me to write these posts), and some of the questions feel more like ill-informed hot takes. I was going to do the same thing with one of the other questions that seems to have been getting some interesting responses, but I've got NaGaDeMon stuff of my own to work on.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Storifying Mage: the Ascension (Part 7) - Skills and Magic

Warhammer Alliance

Game Chef Review 47: QRC ICYMI by John Yanush (Take 2)