An alternate paradigm
I really enjoy seeing how other people view tabletop role-playing games, and I'd love yo know more about the rationale behind his diagram that showed up in my feed. It was generated by John Errwin (@johnerrwin.bsky.social), and when I saw it on my bluesky feed I knew I had to critique it and try to intuit where it was going. I really like the notion that it's a cycle, and that various parts of that cycle influence sequential other parts of the cycle. From the perspective of my own "three-way tension" and "vector theory" about TTRPGs, this whole thing would fit into the "Rules" part of the structure. It's not a perfect fit, but it certainly gets me thinking about how the breakdown falls apart, whether that's my own theories breaking down, or the theories that seem to be alluded to in this diagram. I'll give a description of what I see, then delve deeper shortly. Starting at the top of this diagram, we have "characters", who se...