Players verus the GM (Part 2)
The post breaking down the various Players versus the GM responses was getting a bit long and unwieldy, so here's the second part of it. Totally agreed. Yeah, this is how I run my games, but I know that a lot of GMs don't run their games like this. I've sat with GMs who've done antagonism well, and others who have done it very poorly, including games I've just flat-out walked away from. Once again we're looking at the split between diegetic and non-diegetic in the session. However, in many of the more memorable sessions I've been a part of, players have been playing with the GM, while their characters have been fighting against a combination of adversities created by the GM, by each other, and by the reactions in the world that are showing them accountability for their own actions. When the session starts, characters with true agency won't know where they're gong to end up, they just know that it's going to be an interesting and meandering...