Posts

Players versus the GM

Image
I've been watching some really great discussions on TTRPGs in the last few months. These have popped up on the various social media platforms and in the various online groups I belong to. I wanted to write about them when they first came up, and meticulously worked through the posts cutting and pasting a range of them into a document so that I could respond to them one by on. A lot of this stuff ties into the  Three Way Tension ideas that I've been writing about for the last decade and a half. Much of the problems seems to lie in the fact that people are talking about the same types of things with a different lexicon, or using the same expressions to discuss things with different words. It's that ongoing issue that we've had in RPG theory since the dawn of Tabletop gaming....and probably before. I've left the names of the originators intact, because I'm critiquing the ideas that they've presented and generally linking them back to the "3-way Tension...

NaGaDeMon 2026 - Archetypes

Image
One of the fun things about the way I've structured SNAFU is the way I've structured "clusters" of abilities. Each cluster is a pool of 7 abilities, with a special advantage attached to it. Nothing more, nothing less. From the purposes of a traditional TTRPG, this is easy to emulate.  There could be a range of clusters defining races/bloodlines/genetic-heritages (or whatever your setting calls the assorted groups who populate the world). Seven abilities commonly associated with that group, and an advantage that they are known to have. If you have locked in more of the abilities from this cluster, you're a more stereotypical member of the group.  There could be a range of clusters form the standard occupations/classes. Again, seven abilities commonly associated with those who make their living this way, and a bonus advantage that comes to those who master the role.  To align with more current games, there could be a third category of clusters matching the cultures ...

Revisting alternatives to Hit Points.

Image
 I wrote this post 16 years ago... Alternatives for Hit Points ...and while I've been in and out of the loop for a bit, I've encountered a couple of options, and have designed a few games that have adopted the ideas of other designers.  Penalty Traits Penalty traits are oe of the most common alternatives. If a character takes a hit, physically, socially or magically,they often have to accept some kind of penalty condition until they find a way to overcoime the condition they've been afflicted with. Sometimes I've seen traits applied in combination with hit points, where it's either: A) You take a penalty trait that impacts your ability as well as suffering hit point damage (this often occurs on a critical hit). or B) You take a debilitating penalty trait  or  you accept the loss of hit points (player's choice, or maybe it's a system choice determined by rolling on a table). Usually the loss of hit points is preferable, but if the character is out of hit poin...

Experiments in Progress (Part 4 of 5)

Image
After the issues with last week's lack of a session, we'll probably do a sixth part to this sequence to complete the "five". We had a couple more players lined up, but with our final line-up there were two players. One was he regular who's attended all of my LGS games so far, and one was a fairly new player who knew Magic the Gathering, was starting to play Kill Team in the Warhammer 40k universe, and had a couple of sessions of D&D under his belt. The new player was exactly the kind of person I've been trying to reach with my games, someone who has show interest in that various disparate parts of our hobby, has  sense of adventure, but hasn't been too tainted by Dungeons and Dragons.  So this time we had a warrior and a psyker. No-one particularly investigative, so any mysteries and strangeness would probably lie uncovered during the course of play. I figured that I would explain some things to the players, so they understood the logic of the events s...

NaGaDeMon 2026

Image
 It's that time of year again. (It always seems to be that time of year for something or other). I've finally managed to work out some of the things on Affinity that I had missed... and now that I know how to do them, the rest of the process has actually been a pretty easy process.  So with that in mind, it's time to turn the "SNAFU Basics" pseudo-SRD into the expanded "SNAFU Cookbook". I've been working on this menatlly for a couple of years, there are files around that have started the book in various ways, and there are snippets of ideas scattered through other files... now it's just a time of compiling those files into a semi-coherent, avant-garde, dadaist-punk manifesto. As a continuation of " FUBAR " and running with the Punk/Dadaist/'Zine aesthetic, it will still aim toward the handmade cut-and-paste look. I've been doing this for the games for about 15 years now, and it certainly pre-dates AI, but I'm generally hopin...

Experiments in Progress (Part 3 of 5)

Depressingly, no game this week. Does that mean the experiment isn't as engaging as I hoped it was? Or am I just falling prey to the regular stereotypical situation where it's hard for a game-master to get regular players for a game? Not sure, but it's annoying regardless. Thankfully, it's given me some extra time to get everything in order.  I'll share some of the pages I've generated as player handouts shortly, along with the ways and reasons I've reskinned the game in the ways that I have. For the purposes of consolidating the game, I'm thinking of getting Erin to put the "hack" up on her itch page ( https://erin-gumiho.itch.io/ ) as a Sceletus spin-off... besides, her page is getting more traction than mine lately.  

Sceletus Halloween Sale

Image
Starting tomorrow, for Halloween, Erin has reduced the cost of all the paid supplements for Sceletus. Hopefully a few more people will take advantage of this opportunity. https://itch.io/s/209598/halloween-sale-2026 If we get a few more sales over this period, it might motivate us to finish off a few more of the supplement ideas we've been considering for the project.. and we might do similar sales again in future.