Players versus the GM

I've been watching some really great discussions on TTRPGs in the last few months. These have popped up on the various social media platforms and in the various online groups I belong to. I wanted to write about them when they first came up, and meticulously worked through the posts cutting and pasting a range of them into a document so that I could respond to them one by on. A lot of this stuff ties into the Three Way Tension ideas that I've been writing about for the last decade and a half. Much of the problems seems to lie in the fact that people are talking about the same types of things with a different lexicon, or using the same expressions to discuss things with different words. It's that ongoing issue that we've had in RPG theory since the dawn of Tabletop gaming....and probably before.

I've left the names of the originators intact, because I'm critiquing the ideas that they've presented and generally linking them back to the "3-way Tension" and "Vector Theory" models I've been refining. There isn't much here that goes against that paradigm, in fact, most of the comments reinforce it from different directions.

That's where it all started...

...and there's my response in the group. Based on my avatar, this must have been a discussion on one of the Facebook groups I belong to.

There's something interesting in the way that most players who step up to the role of running games for their friends have often been taught by other people who have been running their own games. They accumulate their experience, pass down their lore, and the style of game is mutated by each new host, or consolidates as an accepted play-style with adjectives like "OSR", "murderhobo", "sandbox" that it shares with established methods of playing. 

Beyond this, it's really an important point that the characters are the avatars of player agency within the diegesis. The more they are around, the stronger their presence, this is generally how it's reflected in games like D&D that generally follow cycles of the heroes journey. I try to avoid killing characters because it immediately ends that player's ability to further impact the story, but it's often considered necessary for dramatic tension to ensure potential death is an option. However, it's possible for the dramatic tension to come from risks to allies, family members, or supporting characters who might otherwise be useful. 

This is an interesting take, and it's a part of the whole ecosystem of play that I've been developing for SNAFU. The metagame of tokens basically starts with the momentum of the story pushing in the direction of the antagonists, and it's the job of the protagonists to nibble away at that, and gradually as they do this, they find it easier to divert the story to an ending they prefer. However, there are so many interpretations of what the "job" of a GM is. From a distinctly finite perspective where they has to be a winner and a loser in the situation, and the story resolves through either the triumph of the characters or their opponents, then the most "satisfying" option might be the one described here. From an infinite perspective, the GM is showing the players the world and balancing their input with the diegetic and non-diegetic rules that govern the play session. From this "sandboxy" perspective, the GM is more of a guide who bring ramifications and repercussions to the actions of the characters, rather than guiding them toward a specifically predetermined climax.

This is certainly a more nuanced take, and one that gets closer to the ideas I have about running a session.

There's a whole genre of game style where the GM doesn't want the PCs to survive. I've seen it done live on stage under a name like "Deathtrap Dungeon" or "Annihilation Alley" with a "celebrity DM/GM" and people paying for tickets to go up on stage and try to survive the traps thrown at their characters for as long as possible. Whoever is the last to survive the dungeon, or whoever is the one alive when the timer expires, wins a prize. Fun is had, people pay good money for it. I assume they're having a good time, but it's not the kind of play that interests me all that much. I find it as boring as watching a session of Critical Role. 

In the "3-way Tension Model", the GM is pulling against the rules and the players, but both of these factors are influencing what they're able to do during the session. If the GM has too much power with regard to the players, it become a situation of player deprotagonisation. Similarly, if the GM has too much power with regard to the rules, it becomes a case of GM fiat. Both should be discussed in advance, and can be potentially detrimental to the session.

Hmm...is it true? They're certainly some of the available RPGs out there, however if everyone is one the same page, doing the same thing then what's giving the session meaning, what is going to be learnt from it, how is it going to be experienced?? Here's where the situations of players versus GM bring tension, having the players identify the best way to portray their characters (working against the tensions inherent in the diegetic rules of the narrative) or confronting the best ways to use the system to achieve their goals (working against the tensions inherent in the non-diegetic rules of the game's mechanics). However this doen't take into account the GM's tensions against the diegetic rules (and trying to move the session forward in a way that maintain fidelity to the events that have already unfolded) or against the non-diegetic rules (and trying to work out the paths of potential futures that can be obtained through manipulation with the rule set that guides the system with utilised). Everyone needs to know when the tension is helping the game, and when it needs to be loosened to allow the session room to breathe. 

Absolutely. I discussed this previously. It's all about the style of play and the agreed parameters of the play experience, even more-so than the specific system being used. The three way tension says that the GM pulls on the session, the players pull on the session, and the rules pull on the session. Swapping out one set of rules for another changes the parameters, but if the rest of the components remain intact, then the new game session will remain a fairly close facsimile of the old one. 

 At this point, I'm similarly reminded of the team of players who showed up to conventions and would play any game with the intention of pushing the pre-written scenario to it's limit then breaking it...they were called Demolition. They wanted to break the GM, break the diegetic rules of the scenario's setting, and if they didn't like the game system they'd push against it's limitations too. Against a rigid scenarios and GM, they'd cause utter mayhem and destruction. I loved running sessions with them, because I'd let them pull, then watch as the sandbox twisted and distorted around us all as an improvisational maelstrom for the duration of the session.

It would be just as pointless if the players easily "won" every session. It's the tension, and the unknown result when various forces pull of the flow of the narrative. Yes, the GM, the players, or the rules could be impervious and omnipotent, but this imbalance typically results in a play situation that remains untenable for an extended period... I often feek that this type of situation is one of the major factors that drives people away from the hobby when they get disappointed in a few too many TTRPG sessions. 

Did they?

Even from the earliest stories of the Braunsteins, there are stories of Arneson and Gygax debating the best ways to present these games where players wouldn't just command abstract groups of troops in conflict with one another, but would portray individual people with their own objectives that may be focused on diplomacy as much as violence. The idea of direct conflict between players and game co-ordinators is more of a personal belief rather than something inherent in the system.

 

 

I'm going to leave this bit here... but I'll add in some more of the responses shortly. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Storifying Mage: the Ascension (Part 7) - Skills and Magic

Warhammer Alliance

Game Chef Review 47: QRC ICYMI by John Yanush (Take 2)